With larger penetrations of wind power, the uncertainty increases in power systems operations. The wind power forecast errors must be accounted for by adapting existing operating tools or designing new ones. A switch from the deterministic framework used today to a probabilistic one has been advocated. This two-part paper presents a framework for risk-basedoperations of power systems. This framework builds on the operating risk defined as the probability of the system to be outside the stable operation domain, given probabilistic forecasts for the uncertainty, load and wind power generation levels. This operating risk can be seen as a probabilistic formulation of the N - 1 criterion. In Part I, the definition of the operating risk and a method to estimate it were presented. A new way of modeling the uncertain wind power injections was presented. In Part II of the paper, the method's accuracy and computational requirements are assessed for both models. It is shown that the new model for wind power introduced in Part I significantly decreases the computation time of the method, which allows for the use of later and more accurate forecasts. The method developed in this paper is able to tackle the two challenges associated with risk-based real-time operations: accurately estimating very low operating risks and doing so in a very limited amount of time.
With larger penetrations of wind power, the uncertainty increases in power systems operations. The wind power forecast errors must be accounted for by adapting existing operating tools or designing new ones. A switch from the deterministic framework used today to a probabilistic one has been advocated. This two-part paper presents a framework for risk-basedoperations of power systems. This framework builds on the operating risk defined as the probability of the system to be outside the stable operation domain, given probabilistic forecasts for the uncertainty (load and wind power generation levels) and outage rates of chosen elements of the system (generators and transmission lines). This operating risk can be seen as a probabilistic formulation of the N - 1 criterion. The stable operation domain is defined by voltage-stability limits, small-signal stability limits, thermal stability limits and other operating limits. In Part I of the paper, a previous method for estimating the operating risk is extended by using a new model for the joint distribution of the uncertainty. This new model allows for a decrease in computation time of the method, which allows for the use of later and more up-to-date forecasts. In Part II, the accuracy and the computation requirements of the method using this new model will be analyzed and compared to the previously used model for the uncertainty. The method developed in this paper is able to tackle the two challenges associated with risk-based real-time operations: accurately estimating very low operating risks and doing so in a very limited amount of time.
Stochastic optimal power flow can provide the system operator with adequate strategies for controlling the power flow to maintain secure operation under stochastic parameter variations. One limitation of stochastic optimal power flow has been that only line flows have been used as security constraints. In many systems voltage stability and small-signal stability also play an important role in constraining the operation. In this paper we aim to extend the stochastic optimal power flow problem to include constraints for voltage stability as well as small-signal stability. This is done by approximating the voltage stability and small-signal stability constraint boundaries with second-order approximations in parameter space. Then we refine methods from mathematical finance to be able to estimate the probability of violating the constraints. In this first part of the paper, we derive second-order approximations of stability boundaries in parameter space. In the second part, the approximations will be used to solve a stochastic optimal power flow problem.
Larger amounts of variable renewable energy sources bring about larger amounts of uncertainty in the form of forecast errors. When taking operational and planning decisions under uncertainty, a trade-off between risk and costs must be made. Today's deterministic operational tools, such as N-1-based methods, cannot directly account for the underlying risk due to uncertainties. Instead, several definitions of operating risks, which are probabilistic indicators, have been proposed in the literature. Estimating these risks require estimating very low probabilities of violations of operating constraints. Crude Monte-Carlo simulations are very computationally demanding for estimating very low probabilities. In this paper, an importance sampling technique from mathematical finance is adapted to estimate very low operating risks in power systems given probabilistic forecasts for the wind power and the load. Case studies in the IEEE 39 and 118 bus systems show a decrease in computational demand of two to three orders of magnitude.
Increasing wind power penetration levels bring about new challenges for power systems operation and planning, because wind power forecast errors increase the uncertainty faced by the different actors. One specific problem is generation re-dispatch during the operation period, a problem in which the system operator seeks the cheapest way of re-dispatching generators while maintaining an acceptable level of system security. Stochastic optimal power flows are re-dispatch algorithms which account for the uncertainty in the optimization problem itself. In this article, an existing stochastic optimal power flow (SOPF) formulation is extended to include the case of non-Gaussian distributed forecast errors. This is an important case when considering wind power, since it has been shown that wind power forecast errors are in general not normally distributed. Approximations are necessary for solving this SOPF formulation. The method is illustrated in a small power system in which the accuracy of these approximations is also assessed for different probability distributions of the load and wind power.
Uncertainties faced by operators of power systems are expected to increase with increasing amounts of wind power. This paper presents a method to design efficient importance sampling estimators to estimate the operating risk by Monte-Carlo simulations given the joint probability distribution describing the wind power and load forecasts. The operating risk is defined as the probability of violating stability and / or operating constraints. The method relies on an exisiting framework for rare-event simulations but takes into account the peculiarities of power systems. In case studies, it is shown that the number of Monte-Carlo runs needed to achieve a certain accuracy on the estimator can be reduced by up to three orders of magnitude.
Summary form only given. Stochastic optimal power flow can provide the system operator with adequate strategies for controlling the power flow to maintain secure operation under stochastic parameter variations. One limitation of stochastic optimal power flow has been that only limits on line flows have been used as stability constraints. In many systems voltage stability and small-signal stability also play an important role in constraining the operation. In this article we aim to extend the stochastic optimal power flow problem to include constraints for voltage stability as well as small-signal stability. This is done by approximating the voltage stability and small-signal stability constraint boundaries with second order approximations in parameter space. Then we refine methods from mathematical finance to be able to estimate the probability of violating the constraints. In the first part of the article, we derive second-order approximations of stability boundaries in parameter space. In the second part of the article, we look at how Cornish-Fisher expansion combined with a method of excluding sets that are counted twice, can be used to estimate the probability of violating the stability constraints. We then show in a numerical example how this leads to an efficient solution method for the stochastic optimal power flow problem.
The uncertainty faced in the operation of power systems increases as larger amounts of intermittent sources, such as wind and solar power, are being installed. Traditionally, an optimalgeneration re-dispatch is obtained by solving security-constrained optimal power flows (SCOPF). The resulting system operation is then optimal for given values of the uncertain parameters. New methods have been developed to consider the uncertainty directly in the generation re-dispatch optimization problem. Chance-constrained optimal power flows (CCOPF) are such methods. In this paper, SCOPF and CCOPF are compared and the benefits of using CCOPF for power systems operation under uncertainty are discussed. The discussion is illustrated by a case study in the IEEE 39 bus system, in which the generation re-dispatch obtained by CCOPF is shown to always be cheaper than that obtained by SCOPF.
n the day-to-day operation of a power system, the system operator repeatedly solves short-termgeneration planning problems. When formulating these problems theoperators have to weigh the riskof costly failures against increased production costs. The resulting problems are often high-dimensionaland various approximations have been suggested in the literature.In this article we formulate the short-term planning problem as an optimal switching problem withdelayed reaction. Furthermore, we proposed a control variable technique that can be used in MonteCarlo regression to obtain a computationally efficient numerical algorithm.
We consider a type of optimal switching problems with non-uniform execution delays and ramping.Such problems frequently occur in the operation of economical andengineering systems. We first pro-vide a solution to the problem by applying a probabilistic method. The main contribution is, however,a scheme for approximating the optimal control by limiting the information in the state-feedback.In a numerical example the approximation routine gives a considerable computational performanceenhancement, when compared to a conventional algorithm.
We consider a type of optimal switching problems with non-uniform execution delays and ramping. Such problems frequently occur in the operation of economical and engineering systems. We first provide a solution to the problem by applying a probabilistic method. The main contribution is, however, a scheme for approximating the optimal control by limiting the information in the state-feedback. In a numerical example the approximation routine gives a considerable computational performance enhancement when compared to a conventional algorithm.
We consider stochastic optimal switching problems with reaction delays and propose an approximation technique that decreases the computational complexity. In a numerical example the approximation routine gives a considerable computational performance enhancement when compared to a conventional algorithm.
We consider the problem where an operator of n production units acts by turning off and on the units to track a stochastic demand. We investigate the situation when the running cost depends on the time that each unit has been in operation, covering, for example, the case when there are delays in the control response. In this setting, standard methods for numerical solution quickly become intractable as $n$ increases. To resolve this we propose a numerical scheme where delay states are discretized with a different step size than that of the time line. We first show that the value function converges to the optimum as the step size goes to zero. We then show, by a counter-example, that the corresponding control does not necessarily converge to an optimal control for the original problem and propose a perturbation that resolves this issue.
Power system voltage security assessment is generally applied by considering the power system loadability surface. For a large power system, the loadability surface is a complicated hyper-surface in parameter space, and local approximations are a necessity for any analysis. Unfortunately, inequality constraints due to for example generator overexitation limiters, and higher codimension bifurcations, make the loadability surface non-smooth. One situation that is particularly difficult to handle is when a saddle-node bifurcation surface intersects a switching loadability limit surface. In this article we intend to investigate how several local approximations can be combined to obtain an adequate approximation of the loadability surface near such intersections.
Lately, much work in the area of voltage stability assessment has been focused on finding post-contingency corrective controls. In this article a contribution to this area will be presented where we investigate the surface of maximal loadability while allowing for post-contingency corrective controls. This objective is different from the usual, where the aim is to include the post-contingency controls in a security-constrained optimal power flow. Our aim is rather to find approximations of the post-contingency stability boundary, in pre-contingencyparameter space, while including the possibility for post-contingency corrective controls. These approximations can then be used in, for example, a chance-constrained optimal power flow routine.
Stochastic optimal power flow can provide the system operator with adequate strategies for controlling the power flow to maintain secure operation under stochastic parameter variations. One limitation of stochastic optimal power flow has been that only steady-state variable limits have been used as security constraints. In many systems voltage stability and small-signal stability also play an important role in constraining the operation. Recently an extension of the stochastic optimal power flow formulation that included constraints for voltage stability as well as small-signal stability was proposed. This was done by approximating the voltage stability and small-signal stability constraint boundaries with second order approximations in parameter space. In this article an alternative solution method to this problem will be proposed. The new improved solution method, which is based on Edgeworth series expansions, is both more efficient and accurate. We also give details on convexity of the problem and discuss some computational issues.
In this paper we show how to build an economically optimal feedback control strategy for the re-dispatch of electricity generation. We assume that the operator steers production in a set of controllable power plants by altering the active power set-point of each generator, within a set of predefined set-points. Theoperators strategy will be based on balancing the operating cost against the expected cost from unserved demand. Important aspects are ramp-rates at which production can approach the set-point, and switching costs arising from increased fuel consumption during ramping and wear and tear on production facilities.
In power systems, the system frequency is a good indicator of the networks resilience to major disturbances. In many deregulated markets, eg the Nordic power market, the system operator controls the system frequency manually by calling off bids handed in to a market, called the regulating market. In this paper, we formulate the problem of optimal bid call-off on the regulating market that the system operator is faced with each operating period, as an optimal starting problem with delays. As general optimal starting problems with delays are computationally cumbersome, we present two alternative approximation schemes. First, we make simplifications to the problem that renders classical solution concepts tractable; then, in a second approach, we define a suboptimal solution scheme, based on limiting the feedback information.
The system frequency of a power systems is a good indicator of the networks resilience to major disturbances. The frequency control is generally a multi-layered control structure with primary, secondary and tertiary control. In a completely deregulated setting, for example in the Nordic power system, the system operator controls the system frequency manually by calling-off bids handed in to a market, called the regulating market. In this paper we formulate the problem of optimal bid call-off on the regulating market, that the system operator is faced with each operating period, as a multi-period optimal switching problem with execution delays. (C) 2018, IFAC (International Federation of Automatic Control) Hosting by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
The system frequency of a power systems is a good indicator of the networks resilience to major disturbances. In a completely deregulated setting, for example in the Nordic power system, the system operator controls the system frequency manually by calling-off bids handed in to a market, called the regulating market.
In this paper we formulate the problem of optimal bid call-off on the regulating market, that the system operator is faced with each operating period, as an optimal switching problem with execution delays.
As general optimal switching problems with execution delays are computationally cumbersome we resort to a recently developed suboptimal solution scheme, based on limiting the feedback information in the control loop.
Power system voltage security assessment is generally applied by considering the steady-state stability surface. However, as seen in the literature, random perturbations can drive the system away from stable operation, long before the steady-state stability surface is reached.
Stochastic optimal power flow can provide the system operator with adequate strategies for controlling the power flow to maintain secure operation under stochastic parameter variations. One limitation of stochastic optimal power flow has been that only limits on line flows have been used as stability constraints. In many systems voltage stability and small-signal stability also play an important role in constraining the operation. In this paper we aim to extend the stochastic optimal power flow problem to include constraints for voltage stability as well as small-signal stability. This is done by approximating the voltage stability and small-signal stability constraint surfaces with second-order approximations in parameter space. Then we refine methods from mathematical finance to be able to estimate the probability of violating the constraints. In this, the second part of the paper, we look at how Cornish-Fisher expansion combined with a method of excluding sets that are counted twice, can be used to estimate the probability of violating the stability constraints. We then show in a numerical example how this leads to an efficient solution method for the stochastic optimal power flow problem.
Operating criteria for power systems, such as the (N - 1)-criterion, are often based on evaluating whether the system is vulnerable to a specific set of contingencies. Therefore, a major part of power system security is concerned with establishing regions in parameter space where the system is vulnerable to specific contingencies. In this article we exploit the possibility of using Monte Carlo simulations to build an approximation of the region, in parameter space, where the power system will remain stable following a given contingency.
Power system security analysis is often strongly tied with contingency analysis. To improve Monte Carlo simulation, many different contingency selection techniques have been proposed in the literature. However, with the introduction of more variable generation sources such as wind power and due to fast changing loads, power system security analysis will also have to incorporate sudden changes in injected powers that are not due to generation outages. In this paper, we use importance sampling for injected-power simulation to estimate the probability of system failure given a power system grid state. A comparison to standard crude Monte Carlo simulation is also performed in a numerical example and indicates a major increase in simulation efficiency when using the importance sampling technique proposed in the paper.
In this paper, the novel method operational risk managing optimal power flow (ORMOPF), for minimizing the expected cost of power system operation, is proposed. In contrast to previous research in the area, the proposed method does not use a security criterion. Instead the expected cost of operation includes expected costs of system failures.
Adequate security margins are commonly applied in power systems by keeping predeﬁned transfer limitsthrough certain transmission corridors in the system. These limits are often set to keep the N-1 criterionstating that the system should remain stable after the loss of any component. For many stability criteria suchas, voltage stability, and voltage limits at speciﬁc nodes, the distribution of the injected power amongst thenodes of the system will be of vital importance. To incorporate this into the analysis of transfer limits theuncertainties in nodal loading and wind power production will have to be considered. In this article wepropose a new method for generating samples of the power at all nodes given a set of transfers throughspeciﬁed corridors of the power system. It is then shown how the method can be used to evaluate the risk ofviolating the system stability limits induced by choosing a speciﬁc set of transfer limits. The method can beused in power system operations planning when setting the limits for trading and transfer between thedifferent nodes of the power system.
In this article we consider how the operator of an electric power system should activate bids on the regulating power market in order to minimize the expected operation cost. Important characteristics of the problem are reaction times of actors on the regulating market and ramp-rates for production changes in power plants. Neglecting these will in general lead to major underestimation of the operation cost. Including reaction times and ramp-rates leads to an impulse control problem with delayed reaction. Two numerical schemes to solve this problem are proposed. The first scheme is based on the least-squares Monte Carlo method developed by Longstaff and Schwartz (Rev Financ Stud 14:113–148, 2001). The second scheme which turns out to be more efficient when solving problems with delays, is based on the regression Monte Carlo method developed by Tsitsiklis and van Roy (IEEE Trans Autom Control 44(10):1840–1851, 1999) and (IEEE Trans Neural Netw 12(4):694–703, 2001). The main contribution of the article is the idea of using stochastic control to find an optimal strategy for power system operation and the numerical solution schemes proposed to solve impulse control problems with delayed reaction.
In this article we investigate how to optimally activate regulating bids to handle bottlenecks in power system operation. This will lead to an optimal stopping problem, and activation of a regulating bid is to be performed when the transfer through a specific system bottleneck reaches a certain value. Compared to previous research in the area the work presented in this article includes a more detailed model of the structure of the regulating market, and reaction times of actors on the regulating market is taken into consideration. The emphasis of the presentation will be application to a two area test system. The method is compared to Monte Carlo simulation in a numerical example. The example shows a promising result for the suggested method.