Available on the Loop political science blog, May 1 2026
This article examines how changing perceptions of United States foreign-policy credibility under the second Trump administration may be creating greater political space for European governments to pursue more independent positions. Focusing on a recurring pattern of US escalation followed by retreat, it argues that credibility, rather than material power alone, shapes the constraints within which allies make foreign-policy decisions. European responses to Israel and the conflicts in Gaza and the wider Middle East are used to illustrate this emerging dynamic. The article argues that Europe is not moving towards complete strategic autonomy from the United States, but towards a more conditional form of alignment in which governments may be increasingly willing to challenge Washington when the anticipated costs of dissent appear lower. It highlights the broader importance of credibility, signalling, and perceived constraints in understanding shifts in transatlantic relations and international power.